Is It Cheaper To Rent Or Buy A Water Softener?

shower head from hard water build up


Are your clothes yellowing or graying? Towels feeling stiff? Or are your showerheads clogging? If so, chances are you’re experiencing the effects of hard water. Over time, the consequences can get worse, taking a toll on the pipes, fixtures, and appliances in your home. For instance, homes with hard water can anticipate up to a 30% shorter lifespan on appliances such as dishwashers than homes with soft water. Additionally, water heaters using hard water could require heating element maintenance and typically aren’t as efficient as systems using soft water.


The solution to these issues and many others is to install a water softener, but there is a lot to consider before taking action. Understanding the best system for your home’s needs, what’s required for ongoing maintenance, and the overall costs are all considerations that will need to be weighed, particularly if you’re trying to decide between buying or renting a water softener.

The True Costs for Water Softener Renters

The idea of renting a water softener might not have crossed your mind, but many local water treatment dealers offer this option as an alternative to the upfront cost that purchasing a system brings. This plan appeals to people who aren’t going to be living in their owned or rented home for an extended period of time. With renting, maintenance or repair fees are usually covered in the monthly payment. As a short-term solution, renting can be a good worry-free option.

Water softener renters may have to commit to a contract term (ex. 12-months) so you need to be comfortable with the on-going fixed cost. Plus, a rented system will likely not be a brand new model that includes the latest technology but is still certainly capable of providing your home with the quality water it needs to operate efficiently. Depending how old the system is, it might need repairs and maintenance during the time of rental. Although these costs are generally covered in a rental fee, renters may be inconvenienced with scheduling repairs with their servicing dealer.

Renters may also be challenged with obtaining permission to install a system in the home they rent since a water softener will fundamentally change the plumbing system of the home. If there’s a hard water issue in a rental property, tenants should first talk to their landlord about buying and installing a quality water softener but chances are they will love the idea due to the benefits it provides the property long-term. Property owners will find they aren’t replacing appliances like dishwashers and water heaters as often when they have a water softener, while you will get to enjoy silkier skin and hair. 

The True Costs for Water Softener Buyers

Purchasing a new water softener has several benefits, many of which result in cost savings. A new unit is going to run more efficiently, which will have a lower cost impact on the buyer’s energy bill. In fact, systems equipped with smart water softener technology help reduce water and salt usage by as much as 50% over standard units. This translates into hundreds of gallons of water and hundreds of pounds of salt saved annually.

Owning a water softener can actually reduce costs throughout your home which means, over time, it could pay for itself. For example, dishwashers require up to 70% less soap, and washing machines need up to 50% less detergent when cleaning with soft water. Since the average American household spends over $500 on cleaning supplies per year, buying and installing a new water softener would save money.

Purchasing a new water softener versus renting gives buyers the flexibility to select a system with advanced technology features. WiFi enabled units are capable of wirelessly sending low salt and service reminder notifications. Owners can view water usage in real time and turn their softener to vacation mode right from a smart phone. This makes owning a water softener beneficial for the home but also provides buyers valuable information right in the palm of their hand.

Although the cost of buying a new water softener is an expense upfront, once paid, that expense is settled. Buyers can also expect fewer maintenance issues with a new unit.

Want the latest technology but still not sure if you can afford the initial investment? Ask your local water treatment expert about financing options. Many professional businesses will offer a payment plan to help you spread out the cost over time, making you the proud new owner of a water softener without breaking the bank. You can even use the money you’re saving in your home to make your next payment!

The Better Decision in the End: Buying a Water Softener

Ultimately, a water softener solves many of the challenges hard water can cause in your home. Over time, it saves you money on appliances, home maintenance, clothing, detergents and soaps, making it a smart investment that may end up paying for itself over time. Purchasing and installing a water softener adds value to your house even if it’s not your forever home. Additionally, owning a water softener offers you the freedom to choose a system that works for your specific water problems and allows you to take advantage of additional features that make life easier.  

Rely on a Water Treatment Expert

An expert from Water-Right’s family of water treatment professionals can create a custom solution based on your unique water needs which often vary depending on if you have city water or well water and what region of the country you live in. With their help, you can ensure the system is installed properly and that your water is being treated adequately. Adding a service plan is additional assurance you are maximizing its performance throughout the life span of your system.

All Water-Right dealers are equipped to help you with your problem water needs.

Click the links above to visit the websites of our trusted brands. For those who have concerns about water quality or potential contamination, you can use our Clean Water Testing service to get the answers you need.

our service area

We serve the following areas

Our Locations:

Clean Water Center
1990 Prospect Ct
Appleton, WI 54914

Clean Water Center
N57W39785 Wisconsin Ave
Oconomowoc, WI 53066
Service Area
Free Quote